Are secrets really kept secret? Are there some secrets that must be told?

FBI Agent Jaxson Locke is sent to Beaufort, North Carolina, to recover a rare car belonging to another agent who disappeared in 1965. All Agent Locke knows before his arrival to Beaufort is that Agent Nathan Emerson went there over fifty years ago to conduct an unauthorized investigation. An investigation into the mysterious deaths of three young women.

Agent Locke learns that during Agent Emerson's investigation, innocent people were killed, and Agent Emerson is still currently wanted for those murders.

Agent Locke interviews the only two living witnesses that know anything about Agent Emerson, but they tell him nothing new. When Agent Locke searches Agent Emerson's car, he finds a journal revealing that the two witnesses know more than they led Agent Locke to believe. Agent Locke goes back to the witnesses wanting the truth, and they finally share with him the Secrets of Taylor Creek.